Bonds Aren't the Safe Side Anymore: A $2 Million Look at Fixed Index Annuities
Bonds lost 13% in 2022 and still charge fees. Here's how $2 million did in bonds vs. a fixed index annuity with a 0% floor, 2021 to 2025.
For decades, bonds were the safe side of a retirement plan. You held stocks to grow and bonds to protect what you'd built. When stocks fell, bonds held steady or rose, and the two balanced each other out.
That's not what happened in the last five years. If you're near retirement or already in it, the old rule deserves a second look, and so do the fees you're paying to follow it.
What changed for bonds
Bond prices move opposite to interest rates. When rates rise, the bonds you already own are worth less, because new bonds pay more. For forty years rates mostly fell, which quietly made bonds a good deal.
Then rates went up faster than at any time in a generation. In 2022 the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, the most common measure of the U.S. bond market, lost 13.01%, its worst calendar year on record. The S&P 500 lost 19.44% the same year. The cushion didn't cushion: stocks and bonds fell together.
Bonds have recovered some since then, but not all of it. Over the five years from 2021 through 2025, the bond index still lost about 1.8%, before a single dollar of fees.
The fees you don't see
Most people hold their bonds inside a 401(k) or a managed account, and those come with costs: fund expenses, advisor compensation and recordkeeping. The 401k Averages Book puts the average total cost of a typical plan at about 1.09% of assets a year, and higher for smaller plans.
One percent sounds small. On a $2 million account it's roughly $20,000 a year, and it's charged whether the account went up or down. In 2022 you paid it on top of the loss.
What a fixed index annuity does differently
A fixed index annuity (FIA) is an insurance contract, not an investment in the market. Your money isn't invested in stocks or bonds directly. Instead, the insurance company credits interest based on how an index, like the S&P 500, performs, within limits it sets in advance:
- A 0% floor. When the index goes down, you're credited zero for that period, not a loss. Your account value doesn't fall because the market did.
- Gains are locked in. Interest credited in a good year becomes part of your protected value. A bad year next year can't take it back.
- A cap on the upside. In exchange for the floor, the credit in a strong year is limited to a cap (for example, 6%).
- No annual management fee in a typical base contract. Optional riders, such as a guaranteed income rider, carry their own cost if you choose one.
A $2 million example, 2021 through 2025
Here's how $2,000,000 would have done over the last five full years in each.
The bond side uses the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index total return, less 1% a year for fees. The FIA side is hypothetical: an S&P 500 annual point-to-point strategy with a 0% floor and a 6% annual cap, no riders and no withdrawals.
| Year | Bond index | Bond account (after 1% fees) | S&P 500 | FIA credit | FIA account |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | -1.54% | $1,949,508 | +26.89% | +6.00% | $2,120,000 |
| 2022 | -13.01% | $1,678,918 | -19.44% | 0.00% | $2,120,000 |
| 2023 | +5.53% | $1,754,045 | +24.23% | +6.00% | $2,247,200 |
| 2024 | +1.25% | $1,758,211 | +23.31% | +6.00% | $2,382,032 |
| 2025 | +7.30% | $1,867,694 | +16.39% | +6.00% | $2,524,954 |
After five years:
- The bond account ended at $1,867,694, down $132,306, after paying about $90,994 in fees.
- The FIA ended at $2,524,954, up $524,954, with no annual fee.
- The difference is $657,259.
The biggest single gap came in 2022. The bond account lost $270,590 that year. The FIA lost nothing: its value stayed at $2,120,000, and the next year it picked up from there instead of digging out of a hole.
The honest trade-offs
An FIA isn't right for every dollar, and it's worth knowing what you give up:
- Some upside potential will have limits. Caps and participation rates vary by product and by insurer, so in a strong market year the interest credited can be well below the index's gain.
- Your money is committed for a while. Most FIAs have a surrender period, often 7 to 10 years, with charges if you take out more than the free amount (commonly 10% a year).
- Caps change. The insurer sets the cap each year, and it can go up or down.
- The guarantees come from the insurer. They're backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the company that issues the contract, so the company you choose matters.
Who this tends to fit
If you're within ten years of retirement, or in it, the question isn't only how much you could make. It's how much you can afford to lose right before you need the money. For the part of your savings that's meant to stay safe, a fixed index annuity offers something bonds no longer reliably do: growth when the market rises and a 0% floor when it doesn't, without a yearly fee taking a slice either way.
If you'd like to see what this would look like with your own numbers, reach out to us and a licensed professional will walk you through it.
This example is hypothetical and for illustration only. It isn't a recommendation or a guarantee of future results, and past index performance doesn't predict future performance. The FIA figures assume an S&P 500 annual point-to-point crediting strategy (price index, dividends not included) with a 0% floor and a 6% annual cap held constant, no riders, no withdrawals and no surrender charges; actual caps, participation rates and terms vary by product, by insurer and by year. The bond figures use the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index's calendar-year total returns less an assumed 1% annual all-in cost, based on the 401k Averages Book's average total plan cost; your own costs may be higher or lower. You can't invest directly in an index. A fixed index annuity is an insurance contract, not a security or a bond; it isn't FDIC insured, and its guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Annuities have surrender charges and limitations; read the contract and talk with a licensed professional before you buy.
Ready to put this into action?
Understanding the strategy is step one. Step two is building your personal plan. Connect with a member of our team, no pressure, no jargon, just a clear path forward for you and your family.
